Cannabis: “Global Commoditization Event”

A global collapse in the price of psychoactive cannabis — a “Global Commoditization Event” — is inevitable.

Figure 1 (below) shows a typical graph of the revenues forecasted for the USA’s psychoactive cannabis industry, 2018-2027 (from data published by BDS Analytics, Marijuana Business Daily, New Frontier Data and New Leaf Data Services).
US Revenues
Figure 1: Typical forecast of the US cannabis industry’s revenue.

As you can see from Figure 1, the industry’s revenue is forecast to rise swiftly from $9 billion in 2018 to $42 billion in 2027, reflecting a Compound Average Growth Rate (CAGR) of more than 18 percent. That makes cannabis one of the fastest-growing industries in America, and, in fact, among the fastest-growing industries in history.

The problem is that “industry revenue” is the combination of two different data series: the good news of rising unit sales, and the bad news of falling unit prices. Showing only the industry’s rising revenue hides the bad news about falling prices.

Figure 2 (below) adds the industry’s falling wholesale price to the same revenue data as in Figure 1 (above).
US Revenues and Prices
Figure 2: Shows the “bad news” of falling wholesale prices (author’s forecast). The red horizontal dashed line represents $500/pound, below which growing cannabis in North America is unlikely to be profitable. The blue horizontal dashed line represents the lowest cost of production in North America ($250/pound).

The wholesale price forecast shown in Figure 2 (above) uses a very simple model: it applies the historical rate of price declines, from 2014 through 2018, onward through 2021. Thereafter, it assumes that cannabis will be legalized at the US federal level, enabling national-scale oversupply that causes the price to collapse towards the “lowest cost of production of psychoactive cannabis of adequate quality” in the USA (estimated at $250/pound), which will squeeze cannabis farms’ margins down to agricultural norms.

Is it possible to forecast cannabis prices? The US Department of Agriculture regularly forecasts, ten years in advance, the price of agricultural commodities such as corn, wheat and soybeans — none of which have seed-to-sale tracking, as cannabis does. So: yes, it is reasonable to forecast cannabis prices.

Is it reasonable to expect such a price collapse?

  • Troy Dayton, CEO of the ArcView Group, said in 2017, “Anybody that is investing in this sector or starting a business in this sector needs to be doing so with the understanding that the price of cannabis is going to drop precipitously.”
  • Dale Gieringer, Ph. D., wrote in Ed Rosenthal’s Hemp Today (1994) that, under full legalization, “the price of legal marijuana would be cut by a factor of 100 or more.”
  • Jonathan P. Caulkins, PhD., concluded in 2010 that “wholesale prices after legalization could be dramatically lower than they are today.”
  • Beau Whitney, Founder of Whitney Economics and Senior Economist at New Frontier Data, has stated that “Cannabis commoditization is inevitable. Those who will benefit from commoditization, such as North America’s consumers and Thailand’s farmers, will love it. Those who think international competition will lower their margins, off-shore their jobs, and threaten their businesses, will revile it. The 64 billion dollar question is not ‘if’ there will be price commoditization, but: ‘when’?”

So: because credible experts expect to see a “precipitous, dramatic” drop in the price of psychoactive cannabis, “by a factor of 100 or more,” yes, it is reasonable to expect such a price collapse.

The figures shown above are based solely on US data. For example, they show the price of cannabis flattening towards the USA’s “lowest cost of production of adequate quality,” estimated at $250/pound.

What happens when the USA’s market for psychoactive cannabis becomes integrated with the global market? Then, the price in the USA can be expected to collapse towards the whole world’s “lowest cost of production of adequate quality,” that is, towards Thailand’s cost of production, which is no more than ($0.05/gram * 453 grams/pound =) $22.5/pound. That’s less than one-tenth of the USA’s estimated cost of production.

At that point, all of North America’s producers of psychoactive cannabis will need to find a new business to be in, just as North America’s cut-flower growers had to do when when out-competed by lower-cost producers in Colombia.

So: Yes, a global collapse in the price of psychoactive cannabis — a “Global Commoditization Event” — is inevitable.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s